I was going to write about the inevitability of a savage media backlash against the YouTube/Britain’s Got Talent singing sensation Susan Boyle.
But it’s begun already.
You see the process starts slowly but it follows a well-worn formula. As news outlets get bored with the story but know they have to keep flogging it, they will quickly tire of the insane “a star is born” hyperbole that has enveloped us now.
Then the tone will slighty change. At first, there will be “concerned” noises about the impact on this on Ms Boyle.
The next phase will be cautious: perhaps a lengthy chin-tugger from a “weighty” commentator about the questionability of this kind of lowbrow culture. Maybe a music critic will give a “brutally honest” account of her singing compared to professionals.
After that it’ll get nasty. Perhaps there will a Daily Mail-esque “Is Susan the kind of role model we want?”. Then a lifestyle columnist will, in an attempt to be controversial, get stuck into Susan Boyle with snide references to the fact she never married. There’ll be a vox pop taking potshots at any financial success she has on the back of her performance. A style “journalist” will have a go at the way she looks.
Then we’ll get into the muck-raking. Hacks will be crawling around looking for scandal: perhaps a never-been-kissed-and-tell (In fact there’s already a comment on YouTube saying: “I know Susan Boyle’s childhood love Patrick Quinn, he is an alcoholic living in Cambridge, I have GENUINE footage of him.” Nice.)
You can bet someone’s checking out the benefits she claimed while looking after her mother. The pubs near her will be staked out in the hope she gets blootered or says something unguarded. The hunt will be on for proof she mimed.
Maybe it’ll get desperate and there’ll be revelations that she once embezzled tent pegs from the Brownies or likes dressing up as Osama bin Laden.
Given its recent form, I fancy the Scottish Sunday Express to come into its own at this stage.
In any case, the process has begun. The Telegraph website has entered “concerned” mode. And, in a taste of things to come, seasons that concern with a wee dig at Susan’s appearance. With her ghastly frock, wedge of frizzy hair and cowboy-like gait, Susan Boyle surprised us all and has since dipped her toe into the waters of fame.
On your marks…
One Response to Susan Boyle: now comes the witch hunt
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Recent Comments
- Ambitious Outsider on Death of Scottish journalism: we name the guilty men
- mark gorman on How to save The Scotsman, The Herald and newspapers in general: a modest proposal
- Alan Rodgers on about
- Stewart on Start your news site now – thanks to Murdoch
- scottdouglas on Start your news site now – thanks to Murdoch
Tags
ads advertising assassin BBC blogging blogs content fiction funny google guardian Herald humor humour internet johnston press Journalism journalist journalists jp Labour marketing media media newmedia journalism new newmedia new media news newspapers ninja online panda Panda Assassin politics print Scotland scotsman scotsman.com scottish SNP terrorism video w00tonomy web Web 2.0Recent Trackbacks
- Tale of an old newspaper shows why paid news websites may be the future after all – Media is Social: Craig McGill, PR, Social Media, Digital: ...
- doctorvee: Iain Macwhirter and the relationship between the media and bloggers
- doctorvee: Iain Macwhirter and the relationship between the media and bloggers
- Disaster lurks for The Herald’s new website: Scottish Roundup: The Week of the Fascist Fonebook (Phascist...
- Rumours Exaggerated - Scottish Roundup: Outbreak of Peace
February 2012 M T W T F S S « Jul 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Flickr Photos





More Photos
My tweets- calgacus: Useful Scots word: peerie http://t.co/payqnk3q #history #scotland
- calgacus: Good coach, poor selector – Robinson lives up to that harsh tag again http://t.co/NpfojEnK #rugby #scotland
- calgacus: Up for grabs: six possible recipients of Goodwin’s cast-off knighthood http://t.co/qhTCFfGt #ukpolitics #rbs
Blogroll
- Alastair McKay
- Alistair Brown
- Black and white and read all over
- Clay Shirky
- Cluttered Desk: Craig McGill
- Complete Tosh
- Corante.com
- Corriganreid
- David Low
- Destruct
- Digital Deliverance
- Doctor Vee
- El Despiole
- Enemies of Reason
- Hugh Martin
- Iain S Bruce
- Jemima Kiss
- Kirk Elder
- Mad Green Ape on SEO
- Meskel Square – Andrew Heavens
- Mike Wade
- Mulitmedia Maniac: Tim Overdiek
- Recovering Journalist
- Reporters sans frontières
- Site Meter
- Stephen C Walker
- Stephen Rafferty, Sure PR
- Stewart’s shared items in Google Reader
- Suggest Ideas
- Support Forum
- The Journalism Iconoclast
- Themes
- Vin Crosbie






piers morgan offering her dinner. if that’s not an unwelcome byproduct of fame, I want to know what is.