Four years ago, I left journalism to venture into online marketing. Two years ago, I decided I still needed to be a journalist (though I still carry on with the marketing bit. It’s where the money is.) Scuzzy and doomed though it is “the craft” does not make me as uneasy as marketing. Bill Hicks explains why:
The Scotsman is dying. So is The Herald. Here are some notes towards a plan to save them – and all newspapers. I’d like to see a consortium to put this into practice and save Scotland’s native, quality, national press for the nation. This isn’t born out of delusion but rather a few discussions I’ve had with like-minded senior journalists who believe that the money can be raised and that this is last chance to save these two titles.
|
On the press Small is inevitable
guardian.co.uk, UK - 6 hours ago Not in journalism. The loss of journalists may damage quality, turning away readers in the long term, but there is no simple way of proving the point. … |
Click to continue reading “guardian.co.uk: On the press Small is inevitable”
I have made a return to newspapers of sorts. My agency, w00tonomy, has formed an alliance with Palmer Watson, one of the world’s leading newspaper design agencies.
Our expertise in online content will help them move into the field of newspaper websites while their knowledge of how design can maximise the appeal of words and pictures adds to our offering to our clients.
![]() Jossip |
The Future of Journalism Is In the Hands of Idiots
Gawker, NY - 8 hours ago Now he’s in an immature fight with Ron Rosenbaum, who is much smarter than he is, if also old and blinkered, about THE FUTURE OF JOURNALISM. … Jeff Jarvis Is Kind of Jerky About Journalism New York Magazine New Media Versus Print Journalism: Finally, a Deathmatch! Jossip Jeff Jarvis Responds: Yes, Journalists ARE Responsible For Death … Silicon Alley Insider all 4 news articles |
Just spent ages trying to get a panel of my picks from Amazon to appear on the blog. No matter what I did, nothing would appear. Wracked my brains for ages and then remembered: I browse with an ad blocker.
Duh!
So if you don’t browse with an ad blocker and are interested in some journo reading, here y’are:
I have just read Arthur MacMillan’s excellent autopsy of the corpse of Scottish newspapers in the British Journalism Review. It is a forensic examination of what’s gone wrong and why there is no hope. And it rightly fingers the muppets and Johnston Press and Gannet who have brought what we laughingly call Scotland’s quality papers to their knees.
However, the article falls into the trap of by implication exonerating Andrew Neil, who is as responsible for the demise of the Hootsmon as the overpromoted local newspaper crowd. While JP has had a massively detrimental effect on the paper and the website, Neil cannot escape blame. Here’s why:
Click to continue reading “Death of Scottish journalism: we name the guilty men”
Ah, what a tangled web we we weave when we practise to write silly season stories about things we know little about.
A key danger of being a journalist is writing about a topic when sections of your audience know far more about it than you. This danger is multiplied when you’re flamming up a total non-story.
Sun and Mail hackette Julie Moult knows all about this after scribbling up some desperate nonsense about a photoshopped image of a politician. (Incidentally, the paper used the image without permission despite repeated request by the creator to stop lifting his work). She made several basic errors in the piece – such as describing what had happened as Googlebombing. (My favourite is the fact-box that says the practice of Googlebombing began in the “early 1990s” – a good trick as the Google.com domain was not registered until 1997.)
Click to continue reading “The ‘Julie Moult is an idiot’ campaign: a modern journalistic fable”
Treehouse Media Project has unveiled a manifesto for embittered journos everywhere. (Thanks to Irish-Swedish internet guru Mark Comerford for flagging this up.) Let me give you a flavour with this superbly passionate line:
Laid off? Bought out? Pissed off? Or just overworked because you’re one of the “lucky” ones still working for the walking corpse that is the daily newspaper? Join us, the diaspora, as we work to recapture the joy and passion of our noble profession.
The project has a noble aim: equipping journalists with the entrepreneurial skills to survive in a Web 2.0 world. It’s right: we should go it alone. But it strikes a bum note for me by starting off its homepage with “F*** Google. F*** Craig’s List.”
Even if this is just a come-hither to embittered hacks, it’s a mistake. Google, Craig’s List and other changes to online advertising give us the tools to be free.
Message to journalists everywhere: The internet is not the enemy, your employer’s business model is.
The internet will last. Big newspaper companies that screw profits out of cowed staff and unsophisticated advertisers are doomed.
Good.
F*** ‘em. Not Google. Not Craig’s List. F*** big media. They deserve to die. They have betrayed our sacred calling. And everyone who’s really a journalist in their hearts, guts and gonads will water their graves in the only way we know how – on the way home from the pub.
I’m inspired by Treehouse’s manifesto. And its prompted me to begin my own. But it’s not a manifesto. It’s a business plan. And while its mired in the net up to its oxters it still has that sickly sweet smell of printer’s ink.
Oh yes, print.
Print’s not dead. It’s just going through a painful adolescence.
Like all true hacks, that ink’s in my blood. Before I moved to the web in 2000, I’d experienced the joy-cum-terror of the “hold the front page” call. Until I became a husband and father, the proudest moment of my life was my first byline (The Scotsman, 1988). I’ll never forget my first splash (The Sunday Mail, 1994) or my first interview (Joe Strummer for The List, 1988.) On my wall I have three copper printer’s plates of The Scotsman from 1972 and 1999 – as well as a framed picture of the first edition of that paper not to carry ads on the front page (1956). And I know that for the consumption of some information print is the best answer.
But it’s only part of the whole picture – and the whole business plan. As I have said many times before, I believe that the net has brought us to the verge of a golden age of journalism. In fact, there has never been a better time to be a journalist. It’s just that there’s never been a worse time to work for a newspaper.
So don’t work for a newspaper. Work for a news organisation which understands the 21st century and isn’t relying on a business model that started looking dated after the invention of radio.
As for Scotland, it has one world-class newsroom in it. One which would stick the heid on the Times, Guardian, BBC and tediously navel-gazing US papers. Sadly, this talented newsroom is spread across dying titles, desperate news agencies and PR-land.
But it doesn’t need to be that way.
Let me paint you a picture of a world of direct communication with the reader. A world that rewarded the best in journalism with the greatest readership. A world of untainted revenue, without advertising department twats in ties with overlarge knots. Imagine a life without 30% profit margins taken out of your pocket. Dream of a life free from megalomaniac proprietors and muppet editors who exist only to trim costs and wouldn’t recognise a story if it kicked them in the old Niagaras with steel-toed boots embroidered with the words: “I AM A STORY, YOU STUPID, PAPERCLIP-COUNTING CHOOB.”
I have seen the promised land. I may not get there with you … but only because I’m going there on a motorbike.
Anyone coming for the ride?
MORE FOLLOWS
I believe this is the first anyway… It’s about my experiences being embedded in the civil service for a while.
Sour Alba podcast 1: Historic first and the civil service [ 2:23 ] Play Now | Play in Popup | DownloadRecent Comments
- Ambitious Outsider on Death of Scottish journalism: we name the guilty men
- mark gorman on How to save The Scotsman, The Herald and newspapers in general: a modest proposal
- Alan Rodgers on about
- Stewart on Start your news site now – thanks to Murdoch
- scottdouglas on Start your news site now – thanks to Murdoch
Tags
ads advertising assassin BBC blogging blogs content fiction funny google guardian Herald humor humour internet johnston press Journalism journalist journalists jp Labour marketing media media newmedia journalism new newmedia new media news newspapers ninja online panda Panda Assassin politics print Scotland scotsman scotsman.com scottish SNP terrorism video w00tonomy web Web 2.0Recent Trackbacks
- Tale of an old newspaper shows why paid news websites may be the future after all – Media is Social: Craig McGill, PR, Social Media, Digital: ...
- doctorvee: Iain Macwhirter and the relationship between the media and bloggers
- doctorvee: Iain Macwhirter and the relationship between the media and bloggers
- Disaster lurks for The Herald’s new website: Scottish Roundup: The Week of the Fascist Fonebook (Phascist...
- Rumours Exaggerated - Scottish Roundup: Outbreak of Peace
February 2012 M T W T F S S « Jul 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Flickr Photos





More Photos
My tweets- calgacus: Useful Scots word: peerie http://t.co/payqnk3q #history #scotland
- calgacus: Good coach, poor selector – Robinson lives up to that harsh tag again http://t.co/NpfojEnK #rugby #scotland
- calgacus: Up for grabs: six possible recipients of Goodwin’s cast-off knighthood http://t.co/qhTCFfGt #ukpolitics #rbs
Blogroll
- Alastair McKay
- Alistair Brown
- Black and white and read all over
- Clay Shirky
- Cluttered Desk: Craig McGill
- Complete Tosh
- Corante.com
- Corriganreid
- David Low
- Destruct
- Digital Deliverance
- Doctor Vee
- El Despiole
- Enemies of Reason
- Hugh Martin
- Iain S Bruce
- Jemima Kiss
- Kirk Elder
- Mad Green Ape on SEO
- Meskel Square – Andrew Heavens
- Mike Wade
- Mulitmedia Maniac: Tim Overdiek
- Recovering Journalist
- Reporters sans frontières
- Site Meter
- Stephen C Walker
- Stephen Rafferty, Sure PR
- Stewart’s shared items in Google Reader
- Suggest Ideas
- Support Forum
- The Journalism Iconoclast
- Themes
- Vin Crosbie


